What if my Addict Partner and I Disagree About Boundaries—Now What?
- Jun 2
- 8 min read
The article, created from PBSE Episode 283, explores the complex challenge of partners disagreeing about boundaries in addiction recovery, emphasizing that boundaries are meant to protect authenticity and safety, not control others. It highlights the addict’s resistance, often rooted in shame, pride, and a desire for autonomy, while encouraging both partners to engage in authentic collaboration by clarifying and communicating their true needs. When collaboration fails, the article addresses the possibility of fundamental incompatibility, urging couples to assess whether their needs can coexist. It distinguishes between consequences and outcomes, underscoring that boundary violations result in natural outcomes rather than punishments. Finally, it stresses the importance of consistent, open communication as a dynamic, ongoing process that fosters deeper connection, emotional safety, and mutual respect, ultimately framing boundaries as pathways to love, healing, and lasting intimacy.
LISTEN TO EPISODE—
Inside this Episode:
Introduction: The Struggle of Differing Boundaries
We know firsthand how challenging it can be to navigate the complexities of addiction recovery, both as recovering addicts and as partners trying to heal from betrayal. In this episode, we address a particularly tough question from a betrayed partner who finds herself stuck in a difficult dynamic: What happens when her addict partner disagrees with the boundaries she has set?
Her situation is not uncommon. She and her partner have engaged deeply in the recovery process: disclosures, polygraphs, impact statements, amends, and consistent work with multiple sex addiction therapists. Yet, they have reached a standoff. She has expressed that one of her core boundaries is that he participates in regular therapy. While he initially agreed, he has begun to resist, arguing that therapy should happen on his terms, when he feels it necessary. This tension raises fundamental questions about boundaries, autonomy, safety, and the nature of true collaboration in recovery.
Many couples in recovery encounter this type of friction, where the initial agreements begin to erode as the addict moves further away from crisis mode. The addict may feel emboldened to relax commitments, while the partner continues to feel vulnerable and unsure. This creates a disparity in perceived safety and progress that can strain the relationship.
In addressing this listener’s question, we aim to unpack the layers beneath these disagreements, offering insights and strategies that can help both partners find a path forward, whether through collaboration or through making difficult but necessary decisions.
Understanding the True Purpose of Boundaries
Before diving into solutions, it's essential to revisit what boundaries are and what they are not. Boundaries exist to serve us, to protect our authenticity, integrity, and safety. They are not designed to control others or manipulate outcomes but to reflect our genuine wants and needs. Healthy boundaries are rooted in self-awareness and personal responsibility, not reactions to discomfort or attempts to enforce power over another.
When boundaries are established correctly, they function like a protective fence rather than a prison wall. They delineate where one person's responsibility ends and another's begins. This distinction is crucial because many conflicts arise when partners confuse setting boundaries with exerting control.
Too often in our culture, boundaries are misconstrued as tools for issuing ultimatums or controlling another's behavior. This misunderstanding can lead to conflict, especially when both parties have differing perspectives on what is reasonable or necessary. In the situation this listener describes, it's crucial to evaluate the original intentions behind her boundary. Is it a reaction to fear? Is it genuinely about creating safety? Understanding these motivations is the foundation for any meaningful dialogue about boundaries.
Additionally, for boundaries to be effective, they must be quantifiable and verifiable. Vague statements like "I'll go to therapy when I need it" lack the specificity necessary for building trust and safety. Instead, both partners must work to define clear parameters that honor each other's authenticity while fostering genuine progress in recovery.
It's also worth noting that boundaries should evolve with the relationship's growth. As trust is rebuilt and progress is made, boundaries may shift to reflect new realities. However, these adjustments must always be mutual and based on authentic dialogue rather than unilateral decisions.
The Addict's Perspective: Resistance, Pride, and Shame
From the addict's side, we understand how challenging it can be to accept boundaries that feel externally imposed. The addict in this situation expresses feeling like his partner is holding an "emotional gun to his head." This reaction stems from a deeply ingrained resistance many addicts have toward being controlled. It can feel like an attack on their autonomy, triggering pride, ego, and even shame.
In our own journeys, we've experienced similar defensiveness. The addict's desire to control the timing and frequency of therapy often masks a deeper discomfort with vulnerability and accountability. Much like a child learning independence, addicts may resist guidance not because they lack understanding, but because they crave control. This desire for independence can lead to avoidance, minimizing the need for therapy until a crisis arises, thus perpetuating reactive recovery.
There is often a deeper emotional undercurrent at play. Many addicts harbor significant shame about their behavior and struggle to face the full weight of their actions. Regular therapy sessions may feel like a constant confrontation with their failures, leading them to resist or delay appointments.
When addicts operate from this space of resistance, they miss valuable opportunities to engage in meaningful collaboration with their partners. True recovery requires the courage to lean into vulnerability, to set aside ego, and to engage with curiosity about the partner's needs.
This resistance can also stem from a misguided belief that avoiding therapy equates to progress. Some addicts convince themselves that if they're not in crisis, they don't need help. But recovery is not merely the absence of crisis—it's the ongoing development of emotional maturity, relational health, and personal accountability.
Authentic Collaboration: Seeking to Understand Each Other
The key to resolving disagreements about boundaries lies in authentic collaboration. Both partners must be willing to explore and articulate their true needs. The betrayed partner needs to clarify what specifically feels unsafe about her husband not attending therapy regularly. Is it the fear of relapse? The fear of dishonesty? The fear of emotional regression?
Similarly, the addict must be willing to explore why he resists regular therapy. Is it shame? Fear of vulnerability? A desire to avoid discomfort? Without these honest conversations, the couple remains stuck in a battle of wills rather than working together to find common ground.
One effective approach involves inviting each other into open dialogue. The addict could say, "Help me understand what's behind your request for regular therapy. What are your fears? What outcomes are you hoping for?" The partner, in turn, can express her concerns in concrete terms, such as observing patterns of reactivity or emotional instability that indicate unresolved issues.
By focusing on the underlying needs rather than the specific behaviors, couples can often find alternative solutions that meet both partners' core concerns. For example, if the partner's primary need is to see emotional stability and consistent engagement in recovery, there may be multiple ways to achieve this beyond weekly therapy.
Collaboration also fosters a deeper emotional bond. When both partners feel heard and validated, it builds a stronger foundation of trust. This mutual respect allows for creative problem-solving and demonstrates a commitment to the health of the relationship over individual preferences.
Moreover, authentic collaboration empowers both partners to take ownership of their roles in the relationship. It shifts the dynamic from opposition to partnership, where both individuals work together to build a shared vision for their future.
When Authentic Collaboration Fails: Navigating Incompatibility
Unfortunately, not all boundary disagreements are easily resolved. There are situations where, after thorough self-reflection and open communication, both partners remain firmly rooted in conflicting positions. In such cases, the couple faces a deeper question: Are we fundamentally compatible?
Compatibility is not just about shared values but about the capacity to meet each other's authentic needs. If one partner requires consistent therapy attendance to feel safe, and the other refuses to commit to that, they may face a core incompatibility that jeopardizes the relationship's stability.
It's essential to recognize that this is not about punishment or coercion. The betrayed partner's boundaries are not ultimatums but reflections of what she needs to feel safe. If her partner cannot meet those needs, she must determine what outcomes are necessary to protect herself, whether that means altering intimacy, living arrangements, or even the future of the relationship.
The emotional toll of reaching this point can be immense. Both partners may feel heartache, frustration, and fear about the potential outcomes. However, acknowledging incompatibility is sometimes the most loving and respectful decision for both individuals.
Incompatibility does not mean failure. It simply reflects that, despite best efforts, the partners' needs and capacities no longer align in a way that supports mutual well-being. Recognizing this allows each person to pursue healing and fulfillment in ways that honor their authentic selves.
Consequences vs. Outcomes: Shifting the Perspective
A common misunderstanding in boundary work is the conflation of consequences with punishment. Healthy boundaries are not about enacting penalties but about acknowledging the outcomes that naturally flow from choices. If a boundary is not met, the resulting actions are not retaliatory but necessary for self-preservation.
For example, if the partner feels unsafe being intimate while her husband resists consistent therapy, withdrawing physical intimacy is not a punishment but an authentic expression of her needs. This distinction helps prevent boundaries from becoming battlegrounds and instead reframes them as tools for clarity and self-care.
Both partners benefit from recognizing that boundaries fulfilled bring positive outcomes, such as increased trust, emotional safety, and deeper connection. Conversely, unmet boundaries signal areas requiring further work or possible reevaluation of the relationship's viability.
Viewing boundaries through the lens of outcomes fosters a sense of personal responsibility. Each partner understands that their choices carry inherent results, empowering them to make decisions that align with their values and goals.
Additionally, this perspective reduces defensiveness. When boundaries are seen as reflections of individual needs rather than tools of control, partners are more likely to approach discussions with openness and empathy, paving the way for healthier communication.
The Importance of Consistent Communication
Throughout this process, ongoing, transparent communication is vital. The betrayed partner should regularly share how her husband's choices impact her sense of safety and well-being. This ongoing dialogue helps maintain clarity and prevents misunderstandings from festering into resentment.
Simultaneously, the addict must commit to honest self-reflection and a willingness to explore his own resistance. Engaging support systems, including therapists, sponsors, and recovery groups, can aid both partners in navigating these difficult conversations.
Healthy boundary work is dynamic, requiring regular check-ins, flexibility, and mutual respect. It's not about rigidly enforcing rules but about creating a safe space where both individuals can thrive together.
Frequent communication also serves as a barometer for the relationship's health. Regular check-ins provide opportunities to address emerging concerns before they escalate, fostering a proactive approach to relational challenges.
Moreover, consistent dialogue reinforces the partners' shared commitment to growth and healing. It demonstrates that both individuals are invested in nurturing the relationship and supporting each other's ongoing development.
Final Thoughts: Boundaries as Pathways to Love and Safety
Ultimately, boundaries are not prisons but pathways. They are not about restricting each other but about defining the conditions under which both partners can feel safe, loved, and connected. When approached authentically, boundaries serve as a roadmap to deeper intimacy and mutual respect.
In this listener's case, the journey involves both partners engaging in deep self-reflection, open dialogue, and a willingness to explore alternative solutions. Whether through regular therapy or other verifiable means, the goal is to collaboratively meet each other's needs while honoring each person's autonomy.
If compatibility remains elusive despite these efforts, it may indicate a deeper incompatibility that requires difficult but honest decisions about the future of the relationship. Either way, the process of setting and honoring boundaries is a powerful step toward healing, growth, and genuine connection.
Recovery is not a linear path, and boundary work is one of its most nuanced aspects. It challenges both partners to grow individually and together, fostering resilience, empathy, and deeper understanding along the way.
As each person leans into the discomfort of these conversations, they build the foundation for a relationship rooted in authenticity, mutual respect, and enduring love. This ongoing journey, while often difficult, offers the promise of profound transformation and renewed intimacy.
If you found this article helpful and are looking for more support, come check out our Dare to Connect program. We offer resources not just for couples, but for individuals on every part of the healing journey. Visit us at daretoconnectnow.com — we'd love to have you join us.
Comments