He has the Right to Completely Screw Up His Life!
- 22 hours ago
- 8 min read
In this article, based on episode 320, we respond to a betrayed partner who separated from her husband of 11 years only to watch his addiction escalate into full-blown indulgence and divorce. We explore the painful but clarifying truth that he has the autonomy—the right—to make destructive choices, even if they devastate his family. We examine possible reasons behind such decisions, including emotional immaturity, avoidance of discomfort, lack of insight, identity confusion, and unresolved mental health struggles—while emphasizing that none of these are excuses. Ultimately, we shift the focus to the partner’s power: accepting what she cannot control, strengthening boundaries, protecting her children from emotional crossfire, and reclaiming agency in her own healing journey. He may choose to destroy his life—but she does not have to surrender hers.
LISTEN TO EPISODE—
Inside this Episode:
He has the Right to Completely Screw Up His Life!
This episode comes directly from the heartfelt submission of a betrayed partner navigating separation, divorce, and the continued spiral of her husband’s addiction.
There are some titles we wrestle with before we record.
This was one of them.
“He has the Right to Completely Screw Up His Life!” sounds blunt. Almost shocking. But the longer we sat with this partner’s story, the more we realized that nothing captured the painful reality more clearly than that sentence.
Because here is the brutal truth: he does have that right.
And coming to terms with that reality is one of the most difficult, yet empowering, shifts a betrayed partner can make.
When Words Don’t Match Behavior—Again
This partner described separating from her husband of 11 years, the father of her two young children. The separation was supposed to create space—space for clarity, space for recovery work, space for him to “work on himself.” Instead, it quickly devolved into divorce. His addiction escalated. His behaviors intensified. His promises dissolved.
She said she had hoped that divorce might “wake him up.” That somehow the gravity of losing his marriage would finally catalyze real, lasting change. But instead, she watched his words once again fail to match his actions. That mismatch—hope followed by collapse—often hurts more than the initial discovery.
There is a unique kind of devastation that happens when you realize you were holding onto something that was never actually there. She described feeling “more betrayed than ever,” because now it wasn’t just hidden acting out. It was open indulgence. It felt like he was finally free to pursue all his fantasies without restraint.
And that’s where the mind starts spiraling: “Is he winning? Is he finally happy? Did I just stand in the way of his ‘true self’?” Those questions are painful. They can feel humiliating. But they’re rooted in betrayal trauma, not truth. And the first step in rising above the trees is separating perception from reality.
Understanding Without Excusing
Before we analyze anything, let’s be crystal clear.
Nothing we explain is an excuse.
We are not softening the damage. We are not minimizing the betrayal. We are not justifying abandonment or escalation. We are simply trying to illuminate the psychological mechanics behind destructive choices so they don’t remain a mystery.
When something feels incomprehensible, our brain tries to fill in the blanks. And too often, betrayed partners fill those blanks with self-blame. “If I had been more supportive… more attractive… more patient… less emotional…” The mind searches for causation because causation feels controllable.
But addiction-driven decisions are rarely about the partner. They are about avoidance, fear, immaturity, and unresolved internal pain. Understanding that doesn’t make it hurt less immediately. But it does begin to pull the shame and self-blame out of the equation.
Insight creates space. And space allows you to stop personalizing what was never truly about you.
The Lack of Courage to Face the Boulder
Addiction is fundamentally about avoidance.
Yes, it involves sexual behaviors. Yes, it involves acting out. But beneath those behaviors lies something deeper: an inability or unwillingness to face life head-on. Recovery requires turning toward the very things addiction has helped someone run from for years—sometimes decades.
Recovery means facing insecurity. Facing shame. Facing inadequacy. Facing trauma. Facing depression. Facing anxiety. Facing relational conflict. That is terrifying for someone who has numbed discomfort through fantasy and pleasure.
For many addicts, the thought of living without their coping mechanism feels like standing in front of a freight train. So instead of turning toward growth, they run back to the familiar. They run toward pleasure. Toward distraction. Toward novelty. Toward the illusion of control.
It isn’t strength. It isn’t authenticity. It’s fear wearing the mask of confidence. And fear-driven choices often look reckless from the outside because they are fueled by desperation rather than wisdom.
The Emotional Peter Pan Syndrome
Long-term addiction stunts emotional development.
We don’t say that lightly. There is research supporting the idea that chronic addiction interferes with certain developmental processes—especially when addictive behaviors begin early in adolescence. Emotional regulation, delayed gratification, long-term consequence evaluation—these skills don’t mature properly when discomfort is consistently avoided.
We’ve had men in recovery say, “I’m 45 years old, but emotionally I’m 15.” That’s not hyperbole. It’s recognition. When addiction becomes the primary coping mechanism, growth freezes. Conflict tolerance never strengthens. Commitment muscles never fully develop.
So when life becomes complicated—marriage stress, parenting pressure, financial strain—the emotional adolescent inside says, “This is too much. I want out.” And the exit door that looks most familiar is addiction.
This doesn’t mean he didn’t love his family in his own limited capacity. It means his capacity may have been shallow compared to what healthy adulthood requires. And that lack of depth becomes painfully visible when crisis hits.
When Addiction Becomes “Authentic”
There is a particularly dangerous stage of addiction where it begins to feel like identity.
After years of immersion, the behaviors don’t just feel habitual—they feel “true.” Some men start telling themselves that the sexually unrestrained lifestyle is who they really are. That monogamy was repression. That boundaries were limitations. That indulgence is freedom.
But here’s what we know: the healthy human brain is wired for connection. It is wired for bonding, attachment, and relational stability. When someone abandons all of that for endless novelty, something deeper is driving the shift.
Often, it’s unresolved trauma. Untreated mental health conditions. Identity confusion. Or profound emotional immaturity. Addiction becomes the false solution to deeper wounds. And when the addiction is threatened, the mind defends it as if it were defending survival itself.
So when a man says, “This is just who I am,” it may feel authentic to him in the moment. But authenticity without emotional health is simply unexamined impulse dressed up as self-expression.
Yes—He Has the Right
Here is the part that feels like swallowing glass.
He has the right to choose destruction.
He has agency. Autonomy. Free will. He can make decisions that devastate you. He can make decisions that harm his own future. He can make decisions that impact his children. And no amount of logic, pleading, or consequence can ultimately override that autonomy.
Acceptance of this reality does not mean approval. It does not mean forgiveness. It does not mean surrendering your boundaries. It simply means recognizing what is outside your control.
The pain often intensifies when we fight reality. “He shouldn’t be allowed to do this.” “This isn’t fair.” “This isn’t how it was supposed to go.” All of that is true. It isn’t fair. It isn’t right. But it is happening.
Acceptance is the foundation of power. Because once you stop trying to control him, you can finally focus on what is within your sphere of influence.
“I Was Victimized. I Don’t Have to Stay a Victim.”
You did not cause this.
You cannot cure it.
You cannot control it.
But you can decide who you become next.
There is a difference between being victimized and living as a victim. Being victimized is something that happened to you. Living as a victim is a state of ongoing powerlessness. And while trauma initially strips you of stability, healing gradually restores agency.
Every morning, you might need to ground yourself in two truths: “I cannot change him.” And, “What can I change today?” That second question is where empowerment begins.
You can change your boundaries. You can change your communication methods. You can change your legal protections. You can change your support system. You can change the way you speak to yourself. Growth becomes your quiet rebellion against the chaos he created.
The Complicated Reality of Co-Parenting
Children complicate everything.
When there are children involved, separation does not equal total separation. Co-parenting creates an emotional mortgage that cannot be revoked. Whether you like it or not, there will be ongoing interaction in some form.
That makes acceptance even more nuanced. You must separate the role of husband from the role of father. They are not identical. A man can fail catastrophically as a spouse and still retain certain capacities as a parent.
Now, if addiction is escalating, legitimate safety concerns must be evaluated. Reliability, exposure risks, emotional stability—these are serious considerations. Legal guidance may be necessary. Boundaries may need to be firm and structured.
But long-term peace often depends on asking: What is realistically possible here? What structure protects my children while minimizing unnecessary war? Thoughtful, strategic decisions serve your children better than emotionally reactive ones.
Boundaries, Not Revenge
After betrayal, well-meaning friends may say, “Destroy him.” “Take everything.” “Make him pay.” That instinct is understandable. Pain wants justice.
But scorched-earth approaches often harm children more than they harm the ex-spouse. Revenge may feel powerful in the short term, but it can create long-term instability that echoes for years.
Boundaries are not revenge. Boundaries are clarity. They define what is acceptable, what is safe, and what consequences will follow if agreements are violated.
Boundaries might include structured communication through email or text only. It might mean third-party intermediaries for high-conflict discussions. It might mean detailed custody agreements. It might mean limited in-person interaction. These are not punitive measures—they are protective frameworks.
When boundaries are designed thoughtfully, they reduce chaos. And reducing chaos is one of the greatest gifts you can give yourself and your children.
Protecting the Children from the War
Your children need stability more than they need vindication.
They need space to love both parents without being recruited into the emotional battlefield. They need to form their own understanding over time without absorbing adult-level rage.
This does not mean you suppress your feelings. You absolutely deserve safe spaces to process anger, grief, betrayal, and injustice. Therapy. Support groups. Trusted friends. Healing programs. Those outlets are critical.
But your children are not your validation source. They are not your emotional partners. They are not the jury in your divorce. The way you speak about their father shapes how they see themselves. Because half of their identity comes from him.
Being measured in your language is not weakness. It is emotional maturity. And it creates psychological safety for your children during an already destabilizing time.
Rising Above the Trees
You asked how to see the forest.
Here it is.
This is addiction. This is avoidance. This is emotional immaturity. This is fear masquerading as freedom. This is autonomy misused.
It is not your inadequacy. It is not your failure. It is not proof that you were unworthy.
Addiction promises liberation but delivers captivity. It offers novelty but erodes depth. It feels exciting in the moment but creates emptiness in the long run.
He may appear “free.” But addiction is not freedom. It is compulsion wearing the costume of choice.
And you—though wounded—are stepping into clarity.
He may choose to screw up his life.
But you do not have to screw up yours.
And that is where your strength begins.
If you found this article helpful and are looking for more support, come check out our Dare to Connect program. We offer resources not just for couples, but for individuals on every part of the healing journey. Visit us at daretoconnectnow.com — we'd love to have you join u
Comments